Charlie Brown is a Resource Guarder?

Yep, that’s right. Charlie has a problem with resource guarding (RG). It was two years ago, during the winter of 2017, (Charlie was almost 6 months old) and we had spent the afternoon with friends and their puppy. We played, trained, talked, and had a great time! While we were there Charlie didn’t want to share a toy with the other puppy. He brought the toy to me and gave it up very easily to me, but then when the other puppy tried to take it from me, Charlie went bananas. He quite aggressively went after the other puppy, and they were separated quickly before anyone was hurt. I felt very alarmed. As a behaviorist, I understood the uphill battle of dealing with an adolescent puppy that didn’t like to share, and was fast becoming a resource guarder.

But what is RG? Patricia McConnell defines RG as behavior that discourages another (dog, human or other animal) to take, or get too close to, an object or valued area in a dog’s possession. This is usually something they find to be precious like food, a toy or bone, sleeping area, or maybe even their person. While I considered writing a how-to prevent/treat/manage RG, I decided instead to just share my experience. 


If you’re looking for a blog post on help with RG please visit this site:  

www.patriciamcconnell.com/theotherendoftheleash/resource-guarding-treatment-and-prevention


When you think about it. We humans as a species practice resource guarding all the time. We lock our doors, we hold our purses and wallets close, we don't allow strangers to walk up and touch us, we wouldn't let just anybody sleep in our bed. Yet we find it wrong for our dogs to display RG.

That same afternoon I returned home with a very sleepy puppy, overstimulated kids, and I felt emotionally exhausted. While I tried to do a little research on dog-to-dog RG, my then 7-year-old son kept Charlie busy with lots of playing. After about an hour, it was time to clean up the toys and feed Charlie. I was walking through the living room when I heard a growl from Charlie. I stopped in my tracks and asked what had just happened. My son told me he had hugged Charlie and he growled at him. I was shocked; my mind was racing, and I asked him how he hugged Charlie. He leans right over, gives him another hug, and Charlie bites him. In that 4 second window of time, my entire world dropped out from under me. How could this have happened? How did MY dog, the TRAINER’S dog, bite? What did I do? How could I have failed so horribly? This sounds like an over-reaction? Probably to you…but at the time, that 4 seconds caused me to question my worth as a mother, wife, dog trainer, and dog owner. Even writing this post, 2 years later, causes me to tear up and want to cry anew.


How did this happen? I don’t think I’ll ever know exactly. This could have been something that just was always going to happen. It wasn’t anything that happened to him, but he just was wired to not want to share. It could have been that he was really tired. He had missed his afternoon nap, and instead of just missing it, he was playing hard through it. He was exhausted. Possibly during his play with the other puppy, things had gotten a little rougher than I thought and he was feeling sore. Maybe it was because it was time for him to eat, and he was really hungry. It could have been because his bladder was really full…like bursting. Immediately after the bite, I took him out to the bathroom, and he went potty for a really long time. Or it could have been just the perfect storm of all of the above. Knowing the why was important to me so I could know how to fix it and make sure it NEVER happened again. But alas…that moment was the start of Charlie’s RG problem.


I couldn’t look at Charlie the same way. I kept trying to see him from the objective trainer’s eye, but instead all I could see was the monster that bit my son. I saw nothing but danger every time I looked at him, and worse yet, I kept questioning my judgement on what to do. That night I buried myself in research on RG prevention, treatment, and management. After lengthy discussions with my husband, breeder, and a dear friend/colleague, I decided not to re-home Charlie immediately. I wanted to try to make it work, I wasn’t ready to give up on his one-time incident. I got to work immediately and tried to focus on his behavior day by day. I kept a journal to help me track the progress. I was prepared that if there was a repeat incident and if at anytime my children were in danger, I would rehome him.


Here’s a snippet of a message I sent to a close friend that was very supportive during that time… 

I feel afraid that I'm doing everything wrong. That I will fail at this. That anyone that might be counting on me will be let down. I'm so terrified of disappointing those that expect better from me. I feel guilty. That somehow whenever Charlie behaves poorly it's my fault. That I did it. That I didn't do enough. I feel pressure to be perfect. That people who know what I do will look at me with disgust and judge me for not being perfect. I've lost faith in myself.”


I couldn’t talk with my friends or family about it. I waited over 3 weeks before I told anyone what had happened and what I was personally struggling with. The first few people I reached out to, reacted first with shock, then with compassion, and some even with judgement. I heard a few “I can’t believe you still have him. If it were me, I would have re-homed him.” It was hard to hear the judgement; I already felt so guilty.

The 1st photo was Charlie at 5 months old, 2nd was taken March of 2019 Charlie chose to sit close to both kids while chewing on a bone, 3rd was taken March of 2019 playing ball with a snowball.

I consulted with other trainers, purchased every book on RG treatment, read every blog post I could find. I spent the next several months working very hard with Charlie, my kids, and every dog that I could to help him feel confident. It was far from easy and yet most definitely worth it.


Over the last 2 years, I have expanded my knowledge greatly with RG. I’ve continued to read books and educational manuals about RG. I don’t regret my decision to work with Charlie through all of this. Since that fateful day, Charlie has shown mild aggression towards people over novelty items and food. With dogs he guards toys, food, and water bowls. I continue at a minimum once a week with his RG management, and many weeks we do high-value exchanges daily. I know going forward, this will be a lifelong journey for him, and I’m ok with that. I’ve come a long way from those dark weeks and months, and I know my worth is not wrapped up in the behavior of those around me.


Thank you so much for taking the time to read this post. If you found this helpful please share on social media. Please visit my Facebook Page for updates.